
Case Studies and Key Learnings
Imagine a workplace culture where there’s excitement in the air, where everything is done to enhance the customer experience, where innovation thrives and teams easily adapt to unforeseen circumstances, where your senior team works toward a shared vision of success, and where people genuinely care for one another, feel recognised and are supported within the organisation.
Cultures like these are not created overnight. They aren’t formed by policy, procedure and measuring Key Performance Indicators (KPIs). High performing cultures have values alignment, mission alignment and low levels of fear. These are cultures where employees are able to bring their beliefs and values and their very best to work- a culture of high engagement.
While culture change involves a process, transformation takes place on the inside. Transformation involves human beings and all of the feelings, beliefs and values that motivate them. We have below three brief case studies, including an overview of concepts and key learnings about transforming culture in three large organisations with over 1000 employees.,
We have selected two organisations in different regions of the world —Old Mutual Group and Unilever Brazil—. These organisations had different intentions and approaches to cultural transformation. The common thread is that they have all used Barrett’s Cultural Transformation Tools (CTT) to chart the path on one of the most critical change journeys in their organization’s history.
CASE STUDY: Old Mutual Group
INDUSTRY: Financial Services
EMPLOYEES: 57,480
OPERATIONS IN: Africa, Asia, Europe, North America and South America
Old Mutual Group is a leading international long-term savings, investment and protection group. Three of Old Mutual Group’s well-known brands are Nedbank, Old Mutual and Skandia.
Transforming the culture across all of the Old Mutual Group businesses started with Nedbank in 2005. It became group-wide when the aspiration of becoming “our customers’ most trusted partner” was articulated as part of the Old Mutual Group vision in 2010.
Organizational transformation begins with personal transformation and most critically must start with, and be modelled by, the leadership team. Work was done with the executive leadership teams to increase self-awareness, build trust in relationships. It required our leaders to start the change journey themselves, demonstrate a difference in the way they interacted both with one another, and their teams. Cultural Leads became the core drivers of this change. They were trained and tasked to work with management teams across the group to cascade and embed the values and desired behaviours.
Organisation structures and processes were aligned to support the development of the desired culture from the top-down, including the group operating model, performance management, selection assessment, leadership development and, most recently, the incorporation of cultural entropy levels (a measure of dysfunction) into the long-term incentive plan for executives. Employees have been left with no doubt that the organisation is taking its values and culture seriously.
“I believe that the culture of our business is critical to its success. We monitor our culture using an annual process of engagement with all our people—the Barrett Cultural Values Assessment. Managers all around the organisation are tasked to address issues raised. We understand and believe in the importance of putting our customers at the heart of our business, and creating the right culture and behaviours to support our vision of becoming our customers’ most trusted partner. This will continue to be critical to our success as we head into the future.”
–Julian Roberts, CEO Old Mutual PLC
CASE STUDY: Unilever Brazil
INDUSTRY: Consumer Goods
EMPLOYEES: 10000+
OPERATIONS IN: Brazil
Unilever Brazil had an incredible legacy built over eighty years, however, in 2004–05, after decades of strong growth, revenues slowed and the business was in need of renewal. In early 2008, Kees Kruythoff, the newly appointed Chairman, along with the Unilever Brazil Board, launched a transformational effort to reignite growth. They recognized a need to not only address strategic challenges and manage operations, but to address the organisational culture as well. They had five big thoughts: (1) accelerate growth; (2) profit out of scale; (3) build sustainable transformation in society; (4) identify capabilities needed to build the business; and (5) take a ‘merged rivers’ approach—cultural transformation and operations (strategy/ Key Performance Indicators), like the two Amazonian rivers that merge, had to be managed in an integrated fashion—not either-or, or even side by side, but together, simultaneously.
The Process
» Developed a shared understanding that the concept of a linear process can be outdated and ineffective. Truly dynamic work with cultures is very much in the moment and allows for human dynamics.
» Utilized Cultural Transformation Tools (CTT) to conduct a Cultural Values Assessment every six months.
» Maintained disciplined attention to implementation over for 36 months.
» Emphasized that leaders create culture. Brought the Board through a journey of personal reflection about their values and the culture they desired to create at Unilever Brazil. The Board led the Executive Team (ET) through the same process. And then, the ET led all 250 managers through the process, as well.
» Established rituals and meaning: regular consistent practices and time for reflection on alignment with key espoused values.
The Outcome
» Revenue grew by 3 percent in 2008, 7 percent in 2009 and into the double digits by the second quarter in 2010. Revenue growth was also driven by increases in market share, not price.
» Entropy, the degree of unproductive focus, fell from 37 percent to 19 percent, and then to 10 percent in 2010. Entropy in the top team fell from 31 percent to 8 percent.
» From a culture characterized by caution, short-term focus, internal competition, and consensus, people now experience business with a long-term perspective, shared vision, teamwork, and a strong orientation toward customer satisfaction and the development of leaders.
“At the heart, we’re encouraging personal meaning. This is where growth happens. To make meaning is human. To choose the meaning we make is to be leaders.”
–Rob Mallick, Culture Consultant, Unilever Brazil
KEY LEARNINGS
“Culture Eats strategy for breakfast,” is a remark made by Peter Drucker. If you don’t have a strong culture, you won’t be able to effectively execute your strategy in a sustainable way. At the same time, if you don’t have the focus and direction of a strategy, you are unlikely to achieve your mission. Your culture—the way things are done around here— provides the energy to align people to strive for a shared objective.
What you measure, you can manage. Even though there is no prescription for a perfect culture, you will need a way to measure your unique culture over time to enable you to manage it. Start by understanding (1) the mission, vision and values of your organisation; (2) the personal needs and what motivates your people and (3) what behaviours and actions are needed to create the desired culture that supports your strategic ambitions. Keep in mind that culture is always changing in response to internal and external influences. It will be critical to track the impact of your initiatives and adjust your course
Leaders model the way. Organisations don’t change; people do. You cannot expect your culture to change unless you are willing to transform yourself as a leader. This requires an intimate understanding of your personal values and transparent alignment to the organisations espoused values. Cultural transformation must begin with authentic leaders who value human beings. Leaders at all levels need to continuously slow down and stay open to the needs of their employees. It is important that they see themselves as a vital part of the whole, and shift focus from self-interest to common good.
Start at the top and the bottom. Culture change must start at the top, with the leadership. This is true, but not the whole truth. You also need to create programs and opportunities to involve employees in developing your culture. You can start in small groups within the organisation to demonstrate the impact of culture change on team performance. For an organisation-wide change, you’ll need to empower leaders at all levels to live and lead the desired culture.
Dialogue is key. Culture is like a living plant that you have to nurture. It is crucial to engage and involve people because they are the expression of your culture. The only way to achieve this is through dialogue, or even more precisely, through co-creative dialogue. Through reflection and conversation, people develop a collective awareness of what’s functional and dysfunctional and begin to define the way forward toward the desired culture
Transformation takes time. “With people, slow is fast and fast is slow” is a remark attributed to Stephen Covey. We live in a world where speed is revered. When it comes to culture, however, speed is not a success factor! This process involves human beings and transition takes place slowly from the inside. So, invest time, and be persistent and consistent, rather than trying to move with speed and expect instant changes.
